Sunday, 27 January 2013

Columbus learns wisdom from the Muslims por V1683

I've watched quite a lot of Spanish historical fiction series on DVD in the last year, and perhaps I'll make a fuller post about how they typically portray the Muslims sometime later. In general, its what you would expect given the age of lunacy we live in. Spaniards who advocate taking their country back from the invaders who have occupied it are depicted as sinister, scheming extremists, while those who urge convivencia and accommodation are viewed positively.

Recently I watched an old series called Requiem for Granada on DVD. It tells the story of the recapture of Granada, and focuses on the Muslim perspective. The Muslim characters are played by Europeans "darked up". I always find it amusing when television series or films bearing an "anti-racist" message have the non-European characters played by Europeans. People feel a natural affinity for those who are genetically like them, and this manifests itself in a certain physical repulsion from those who are unlike them. This instinct is the reality that underlies the mythology of racism. But, of course, while purporting to challenge it, the television studios and film directors are actually pandering to it by having the brown people played by Whitey.

In general, Requiem for Granada depicts the Muslims as being a kind of civilised master race, whose wisdom and and refinement contrasts with the crudity of the Christians. The Christian characters, including Fernando and Isabel, take up very little screen time. The story is told from the Muslim perspective. When they do appear, Christians are shown as shallow, fanatic and one-dimensional, albeit cunning. They win by guile rather than bravery or skill.

The most laughable aspect of the pro-Muslim propaganda the series contains is the claim depicted most succinctly in this scene: that the Muslims had discovered the route to Americas and designed ships that could sail it, but somehow never had time to put their plans into action because war with the Christians distracted them. The scene comes close to the end of the series. Granada is besieged by Christian armies. The end is near. Before it comes, however, Christopher Columbus sneaks in to consult with some old learned Muslim to learn his secrets. The Muslim explains to him how to get to the Americas.

It's interesting that this series (a joint Spanish/Italian production) was produced around 1990. This was before there had been any significant Muslim re-colonisation of Spain, so it cannot have been internal pressures produced by the alien presence that produced this kind of propaganda fantasy, of the kind we have since grown used to.

Incidentally, the DVDs have subtitles in English, German, French, Italian and Portuguese if anyone is thinking of ordering it.


Anonymous said...

Sure, sure, muslims claim they invented everything, but the only real thing they invented probably was the underwear bomb. Who else but the muslims who would create such invention?

Anonymous said...

I'm well aware of some the ridiculous claims that muslims and lefties make for islam - the "Piri Reis" map is an interesting anomaly though - google it if you don't know what it is.

Cyrus said...

It is worth pointing out that the Piri Reis map was the product of Turkish spycraft rather than, as is sometimes claimed, Turkish seamanship. Essentially, the Turks would sometimes storm a European ship and try to steal its charts, from which they gained the knowledge that ended up in the Piri Reis map.

The Turkish fleets never went much further than the Mediterranean or the Indian Sea.

Anonymous said...

What a coincidence - the overwhelming preponderance of inventions alleged to have been developed by Muhammedans never gained traction anywhere in the muslim world, leaving no archeological or anthropoligical evidence of such great achievements yet somehow we are to believe they invented it all.

Anonymous said...

I stumbled upon your page here because I am curious about hate-monger Dan Hodges of the Daily Telegraph. I have found most of what I've read here, while it would be amusing (and it is humorously literate) were it a Chris Morris spoof, stunningly ill-conceived and disturbing. I'm not a big fan of militant Islam or militant anything, but can we all stop spreading hate and bullshit about each other. Maybe take a month off and spend the saved time trying to get to know some people from different backgrounds. You might change your mind. Good luck.

Blog Archive

Powered by Blogger.

Blog Archive

Total Pageviews